"... It is the two singers who lifted the production from this chaotic approach. [...] Michael Nagy's dark baritone gave his Count Gil considerable dramatic pitch. The natural heaviness of his voice made his suspicions seem desperate and wrought with hysteria."bachtrack.com, Zenaida des Aubris, 4/28/2021 - "No smoke without fire? Susanna's Secret revealed at Bayerische Staatsoper"
"... a massive piece of music carved into granite, which cuts off the ornament of the verses and demands a strong interpreter with a no less strong voice. Michael Nagy has both: power and intensity. And with a lyrically grounded voice, he can elicit a wealth of nuances from the bitter permanent Forte and illustrate the psychological process with the finest shades, which in six songs leads from fear of death to remorse to the idea of salvation."Abendzeitung Munich, Robert Braunmüller, 6/7/2020 - "'Jedermann' mit Michael Nagy und Nikolaus Bachler"
"... The casting of the opera is impressive throughout this recording [...]. Michael Nagy is a very convincing prisoner, his voice expressing and ‘recording’, like some sort of scientific instrument, the fluctuations of his emotions. It is impossible not to identify with his hopes and his fears."Musicweb International, Glyn Pursglove, Luigi Dallapiccola "Il Prigioniero"
"The voice and body was that of Michael Nagy. The voice was a glorious heldenbaritone, a voice which plunged down to a low C (along with the contrabassoon), or led upwards at the end with Wagnerian gloriousness. His body? Mr. Nagy was almost paralyzed. He moved his arms to turn the score, but otherwise, this was the Body as Corpse. Frightening stuff."concerto.net, Harry Rolnick, 11/14/2019 - "Schoeck Treatment!"
"Michael Nagy sang Tamare with impeccable intonation and a generous, round baritone."VAN Magazine, Ben Miller 2/15/2018 - "Awful Magic"
"Michael Nagy is a powerfully charismatic presence as Tamare and delivers his notes impressively and forcefully."bachtrack.com, Hugo Shirley, 1/23/2018 - "Toy Story: Calixto Bieito stages Die Gezeichneten at the Komische Oper"
"Michael Nagy, with his rich baritone and sensuous legato, is fittingly seductive but despicable as Tamare."Financial Times, Rebecca Schmid, 1/24/2018 - "Die Gezeichneten, Komische Oper Berlin - tasteless banality"
"Michael Nagy, who was making his CSO debut, sang of finding solace in the face of mortality. To his several solos he bought a burnished, focused lyric baritone with superb projection, pliant phrasing and a lieder singer's regard for the German texts and the meanings they convey through Brahms' music. The Hungarian singer is a real find."Chicago Tribune, John von Rhein, 11/12/2016,
"Magnificent and almost over-casted for the rowdy role: the young, accomplished and powerful Michael Nagy as Kurwenal."Opernwelt, Stephan Mösch, Edition No. 5 / May 2016 - "Über allen Gipfeln keine Ruh'"
"Amongst the soloists the undoubted star is the young [...] bass, Michael Nagy, whose accomplished portrayal of Elijah balances the requisite qualities of patriarchal strength and human vulnerability."Limelight magazine, Tony Way, 4/26/2017 ("Alt-Mendelssohn brings a leaner take on the classic oratorio")
"Young Michael Nagy is already to be numbered among the finest Wolframs I have experienced, and he will only get better with age. His mellifluous, honeyed baritone is sizable enough to ring out in the house, and nuanced enough to create a musically diverse portrayal. And he is highly persuasive as an actor, remaining sympathetic even as the director has Wolfram kill Elisabeth (whom he loves) by stuffing her through a door into a gas tank, and then proceeding to sing a ravishing “Ode to the Evening Star”…to a pregnant Venus. Yes, somehow we still manage to love him, Michael is that good."Opera today, 8/30/2011
"Michael Nagy’s strong, easily projected baritone conveyed the stern admonitory passages without losing a humane expression in his warnings of the finality of death and the transitory nature of earthly life."Chicago Classical Review, Lawrence A. Johnson, 11/11/2016
"Michael Nagy offers an engaging, robustly sung Papageno, ..."The New York Times, George Loomis, 3/26/2013 - "'Zauberflöte' in a New Easter Home"
"Michael Nagy carves out the title role as a magnificent psychological study and is capable of handling every single note of the demanding score."Nachrichten.at, Michael Wruss, 9/15/2015 - „Gruselgeschichte zwischen Geisterwelt und Dorfleben. Saisonauftakt mit "Hans Heiling" im Theater an der Wien”
"Michael Nagy, acclaimed ‚Wolfram‘ of Bayreuth Festival’s „Tannhäuser“-production delivers a masterpiece as Papageno. "Die Welt, Lucas Wiegelmann, 3/24/2013 - "Kann Mozarts 'Zauberflöte' den Tod überwinden?"
"Hats off! This man is a revelation!"Abendzeitung Munich, Robert Braunmüller, 11/13/2011 - "Mahler 'Wunderhornlieder', Sinfonieorchester des BR, Daniele Gatti"
"But the big surprise – and the biggest ovation – went to newcomer Michael Nagy as Wolfram. Here’s another young guy who has everything going for him, especially with respect to technique, breathing, shading and all the little tools that master singers employ, not to mention respect for the score. He’s also the most sympathetic character in the opera, and is not at all hard on the eye. So some wishes did come true."Musical America, 8/15/2011
"Staged like a sung play and relying on the subtle acting skills of a fine ensemble cast – led by the vocally outstanding Michael Nagy as the pacifist protagonist who defies family tradition and honour by refusing to become a soldier- ..."The Sunday Times, 1/31/2010 (Britten Owen Wingrave)
"The performances all seem to me exemplary. Michael Nagy sings well; he has a rich fruity baritone and he really projects the words. The final song in its orchestral version sounds like a riposte to Alberich’s renunciation of love which sets the tragedy of Wagner’s Ring in motion."Musicweb International, Stephen Barber, April 2017 (CD Brahms / Glanert, Four Preludes and Serious Songs)